When it comes to custom engagement rings, it’s not just the diamond that matters—the metal you choose sets the tone for the entire piece. Whether you’re drawn to the classic shine of platinum, the timeless warmth of yellow gold, or the soft romance of rose gold, your metal choice plays a big role in durability, aesthetics, and overall vibe.
At Mark Katzeff Jewellery in Edmonton, we walk clients through every decision—from stone selection to the final polish. And one of the most common questions we get is: platinum vs gold vs rose gold—which one is best? That’s what we’re breaking down today.
Key Takeaways
- Platinum is hypoallergenic, very durable, and has a naturally white luster—but comes at a higher price.
- Yellow gold is traditional and rich-looking, available in different karats depending on durability and cost.
- Rose gold offers a romantic pink tone, is great for vintage lovers, and tends to be more affordable.
- Your lifestyle, skin tone, and personal style should all influence your choice.
- Mark Katzeff crafts custom jewelry using all metal types, guiding you toward a piece that lasts a lifetime.
Why the Right Metal Matters
The metal in your engagement ring or custom jewelry isn’t just a background player—it affects everything from how the ring wears over time to how the stone looks on your finger. Some metals show scratches more easily, others develop a patina, and some look better on certain skin tones.
Let’s walk through the most popular choices side-by-side.
Platinum vs Gold vs Rose Gold: What’s the Difference?
Platinum: The Premium Powerhouse
Platinum is known for its strength and prestige. It’s heavier than gold, giving it a substantial feel. It’s naturally white, so it won’t fade or change color over time—perfect for showcasing diamonds.
Pros of Platinum:
- Extremely durable and long-lasting
- Hypoallergenic (great for sensitive skin)
- No need for rhodium plating (unlike white gold)
Considerations:
- More expensive than gold
- Scratches can develop a matte patina (some love it, some don’t)
- Heavier feel—some people prefer something lighter
[sora: close-up of a platinum engagement ring on a jeweler’s workbench]
Alt text: Platinum engagement ring crafted by expert goldsmith in Edmonton
Yellow Gold: The Traditional Favorite
Yellow gold never goes out of style. It’s warm, elegant, and has been used in jewelry for centuries. You can find it in different purities, usually 14K and 18K for engagement rings.
Pros of Yellow Gold:
- Classic and timeless look
- Softer on the budget than platinum
- Easy to work with during resizing or remodeling
Considerations:
- Softer metal = more prone to scratches over time
- Might require more frequent maintenance for high-polish styles
- May not suit all skin tones
[sora: side-by-side comparison of yellow gold, rose gold, and platinum rings under soft lighting]
Alt text: Comparison of yellow gold, rose gold, and platinum rings at Edmonton jewellery store
Rose Gold: Soft, Romantic, and Vintage-Inspired
Rose gold has seen a major resurgence in the past decade. Its pinkish hue flatters many skin tones and brings a unique, romantic vibe to custom jewelry pieces.
Pros of Rose Gold:
- Unique and eye-catching color
- Often more affordable than platinum and yellow gold
- Vintage appeal for those who want something less traditional
Considerations:
- Contains copper, which can cause allergies for some people
- May darken slightly over time (which many love for the antique look)
- Less common in men’s bands, though that’s changing
[sora: rose gold engagement ring set on a lace fabric with soft natural light]
Alt text: Romantic rose gold engagement ring designed by Edmonton jewellery designer
Which Metal Is Right for You?
Let’s break it down based on what matters most to you.
1. Durability and Maintenance
- Platinum wins for durability. It’s resistant to daily wear and doesn’t lose metal over time—it just displaces it.
- Yellow gold is more prone to scratches and bending, especially at higher karats.
- Rose gold falls somewhere in between—its copper alloy adds hardness.
2. Budget
- 14K yellow or rose gold is often the most affordable.
- 18K options are more luxurious but softer.
- Platinum is the highest price point but lasts longest without fading.
3. Skin Sensitivity
- Platinum is the top choice for sensitive skin—pure and hypoallergenic.
- Yellow gold is usually safe, especially at higher karats.
- Rose gold may cause irritation in people with copper sensitivity.
4. Style and Skin Tone
- Yellow gold complements warmer skin tones.
- Platinum and white gold flatter cooler complexions.
- Rose gold is versatile and romantic, often suiting both cool and warm undertones.
[sora: woman trying on multiple metal rings in a boutique jewellery store setting]
Alt text: Client exploring metal options at Mark Katzeff Jewellery Store in Edmonton
Platinum vs Gold vs Rose Gold: Visual Cheat Sheet
| Feature | Platinum | Yellow Gold | Rose Gold |
|---|---|---|---|
| Color | Silvery-white | Warm yellow | Blush pink |
| Durability | Very high | Moderate | High |
| Price Range | $$$ | $$ | $–$$ |
| Hypoallergenic | Yes | Usually | No (copper alloy) |
| Best For | Classic, durable | Timeless, traditional | Romantic, unique |
What About Mixed Metals?
If you’re having a hard time choosing, why not go for both?
Mark Katzeff offers custom mixed-metal designs—a platinum ring with yellow gold accents, or rose gold bezel around a white gold band. These are perfect for clients who want versatility or to incorporate heirloom metals.
Mixed metals also allow you to tie your ring into other jewelry you wear regularly, making it easier to coordinate daily looks.
[sora: custom mixed-metal ring with diamond center stone and detailed engraving]
Alt text: Custom mixed-metal diamond ring designed by goldsmith in Edmonton
What About White Gold?
You might be wondering: why haven’t we mentioned white gold?
White gold is technically a gold alloy (mixed with white metals like palladium or nickel) and often plated with rhodium to achieve that bright white look. While beautiful, white gold requires more maintenance to keep its silvery finish, making it less ideal if you want a low-maintenance piece.
That said, Mark Katzeff does work with white gold for clients who love its look and want something a little more budget-friendly than platinum.
What Does Mark Katzeff Recommend?
Each metal has its place—but at Mark Katzeff Jewellery in Edmonton, it’s not about which one is “best.” It’s about what suits you.
Mark sits down with each client to understand their lifestyle, preferences, and long-term goals for their jewelry. From there, he can recommend a metal that balances form, function, and beauty—so your ring isn’t just stunning on day one, but for decades to come.
Final Thoughts: Platinum vs Gold vs Rose Gold
Your engagement ring or custom piece is a symbol of love, commitment, and identity. Choosing the right metal—whether platinum, yellow gold, or rose gold—ensures that symbol stands the test of time.
No matter what metal you choose, the artistry and intention behind the design matter just as much. That’s where Mark Katzeff’s decades of experience and one-on-one service make all the difference.
Ready to Get Started?
Whether you’re still deciding between platinum vs gold vs rose gold or you already have a vision in mind, Mark Katzeff is here to help you bring it to life.
Book a consultation today and explore your options in-person at Edmonton’s premier custom jewelry studio.
We also offer an extensive collection of custom and stock rings:
- Engagements Rings
- Wedding Rings
- Ladies wedding rings
- Men’s wedding bands
Let Mark Katzeff help you find what you want that not only inspires you but meets your budget. Call for a free consultation today!
Out Of Town Custom Jewellery Store Customers
Mark Katzeff attracts clients from all over the world to visit his unique jewellery store in Edmonton, here are some of his top links in staying here when meeting with our team, try some of the other attractions!!